The ‘maverick’ Church of England lost some
600 members yesterday – leading one wit to comment that they had given up
church for Lent. They left for many reasons but it would appear that the
Anglicans’ decision to ordain women as bishops was the final straw for them.
Whether they are right or wrong is not for
me to say but under proposals drawn up by Pope Benedict, they will join a brand
new branch of the Roman Catholic Church in England – namely the
Ordinariate. While they left the C of E yesterday, however, they will not join
the Catholic Church until Easter, leaving them 40 days – dare I say it – in
limbo.
Two questions: First, when I (under
compulsion) studied Early Church history, or patristics, as an undergraduate I
was taught the Latin phrase ‘extra ecclessiam nulla salus’ – ‘outside of
the church there is no salvation’; I wonder how this key Catholic doctrine is
dealt with in this circumstance?
Second, now that they find themselves
between two churches, do they still consider themselves to still be a part of
the body of Christ? And if so how would they reconcile this situation with
needing to be a part of any ecclesiastical tradition?
Any thoughts?